The Affordable Care Act: They Gave It the Wrong Name!

As the owner of a new plastic surgery practice in San Francisco, I’m taking on some new employees and I want them to have health insurance.  I could have purchased a group health plan but the high rates and poor coverage seemed oxymoronic. What I mean is that typically you would assume a plan with expensive up front premiums would reduce your out-of-pocket expenses, i.e., lower your deductible, but the group plans I saw didn’t do that. The premiums were high and so were the deductibles, opposite of what you’d expect, ergo, oxymoronic.

 

So I called an insurance broker at California Health Plans to check rates on individual plans with the idea that I would have my employees discuss their insurance needs with the agent, choose the individual rather than group plan that best fit their needs and I would then help them purchase that plan. This process went relatively smoothly but there was a catch.

 

affordable care act

The agent explained that whatever plan we chose, it would end on December 31st. At that point, with the implementation of the Affordable Care Act on January 1st, 2014, we will need to sign on again to this same plan or change plans. The reason we’ll need to “re-up” is that all of the plans regardless of your condition or health, will all go up in cost. Mostly, from what I understand, the extra cost will go towards subsidizing premiums for others that have pre-existing conditions. Since pre-existing conditions can no longer be a reason to deny coverage (which of course everyone agrees with), that does require the insurance company to take on more risk of insuring those individuals and therefore, it costs more. But rather than making those individuals pay exorbitantly more, that extra cost is spread around to everyone to help shoulder the burden (which maybe not everyone agrees with but I do).

 

But here’s the thing with all of our costs going up. Most Americans are thinking this major new piece of healthcare legislation, the Affordable Care Act, is going to make health insurance more affordable. Why do most Americans think it’s going to be more affordable? Picture me with my hands cupped on both sides of my mouth screaming, “BECAUSE IT’S GOT THE WORD ‘AFFORDABLE’ IN IT!” And the word affordable suggests, I think reasonably, that current health insurance premiums will be more affordable, thus less expensive but this is not the case. Clearly, unarguably, they will be more expensive.

 

I’m not saying this as right-wing Republican pundit because I’m an independent – it says so on my voter registration card that I filled out at the San Francisco DMV on Tuesday. I’m saying this as a clear fact. And if you don’t believe me, as I referenced in this blog post, critics and supporters alike all agree that premiums will go up but the amount they’ll go up is apparently up for debate.  The Editorial Board of the New York Times recently praised Obamacare based on early reports from Covered California – the California health care exchange. They were pleased that Blue Cross-Blue Shield would only raise premiums 13%! Why are they happy with a 13% increase – I thought premiums were supposed to go down or be more affordable?

 

Also, in a Forbes article, Avik Roy quotes a recent press release from Covered California that “the rates submitted to Covered California for the 2014 individual market ranged from two percent above to 29 percent below the 2013 average premium for small employer plans in California’s most populous regions.”  Peter Lee, the executive director of Covered California said, “this is a home run for consumers in every region of California.”  But according to Roy, this is misleading. Obamacare will increase individual-market premiums by an average of 116 percent based on his analysis.

 

Politicians and pundits can all argue for their side or their business interests but the average American will be shocked to find out that the Affordable Care Act will make their premiums LESS affordable. This point can not be argued otherwise. It’s basic – more expensive translates to less affordable in most American’s lexicon. What’s the answer to our healthcare quagmire? I don’t know but they probably should’ve started by giving the legislation a better name!

 

 

5 thoughts on “The Affordable Care Act: They Gave It the Wrong Name!

  1. Ask the agent how big the percentage increase was last year. I’ll bet it was in the 20% range. Maybe then ACA is keeping healthcare costs in check, making it more affordable. I’m seeing stories in various regions implementing exchanges and the costs are coming down for some, and insurance is affordable for some who have been placed out of the market. The ACA is not just about insurance prices, but making health care available and affordable to people not able to afford it under the prior model.

    • Excellent points. After I posted this blog the other day, I discussed it with a non-healthcare professional and he suggested similar points. And it actually speaks to what I was suggesting – even if it’s not necessarily the Affordable Care Act in the sense that it’s more affordable, I think it will be the Accessible Care Act, as in it will be more accessible to those that didn’t have access before (consumers with pre-existing conditions, low-income consumers, etc). Thanks so much for the feedback. I’m posting another blog article that references an interesting article in the New York Times from today. Please feel free to comment there as well.

  2. Pingback: High Deductible Health Plans Make for Better Consumers of Healthcare

  3. Pingback: If you like your health insurance plan, you can keep it! Dr. J Kaplan

  4. Pingback: limitations-plans-affordable-care-act

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *